How Giants Became Dwarfs
In certain Lake Tanganyika cichlids breeding in empty snail shells, there are two extreme sizes of males: giants and dwarfs. Researchers from the University of Bern and the University of Graz have analysed the genomes of these fish and found out how the peculiar sizes of males and females evolved in conjunction with the genetic sex determination mechanism.
Difference in body size (or sexual dimorphism) between males and females is common across the animal kingdom. One of the most extreme examples of sexual dimorphism is found in the cichlid fish species Lamprologous callipterus from Lake Tanganyika in East Africa, where males are 12 times bigger (heavier) than females. The ecological reason for this remarkable size difference is the fact that this species uses empty snail shells found at the bottom of the lake to build nests. Hence males must be large enough to carry shells with their mouths, whereas females need to be small enough to fit inside the snail shells to lay eggs, where they are well protected from predators. Sex-specific differences in body size are important for the biology of this species, as small males would not be able to carry empty snail shells and large females would not be able to enter the shells for breeding.
The most peculiar feature of this species, however, is the existence of a second male morph, which is 60 times smaller (lighter) than the nest-building giants. These small fellows sneak into the shells when a female is spawning, only to fertilise there the freshly laid eggs. It had been shown already that the giant nest males and the dwarf parasites only sire sons developing into the same male type as their father. In a new study published in Molecular Ecology, Pooja Singh, formerly from the University of Graz, now located at the Institute of Ecology and Evolution (IEE) of the University of Bern and at Eawag, Michael Taborsky and Catherine Peichel from the Institute of Ecology and Evolution of the University of Bern, and Christian Sturmbauer from the University of Graz, unravelled how the alternative sizes and different sexes are determined in these cichlids.
The genetic mechanism underlying this unique reproductive system
Genomic analyses revealed a Y sex chromosome region differing between males and females. “This was a first important step, because these cichlids lack the highly differentiated sex chromosomes we know from humans and many other animals”, says Pooja Singh, first author of this publication. This was exactly the worthwhile challenge, because thereby the early stages of sex chromosome evolution could be reconstructed in connection with a size-determining genetic mechanism that appeared to be influenced by intra- and intersexual conflict.
The researchers found that this small y-like genomic region contained also the growth hormone regulator gene GHRHR, which was intriguing. “This gene is known to serve an important regulatory function for growth in mammals, and mutations of this gene may lead to dwarfism also in humans”, explains co-author Katie Peichel. As this gene has been identified now also in fishes, it has probably emerged more than 440 million years ago, before aquatic vertebrates conquered terrestrial domains. In the studied snail shell brooding cichlids this size regulating gene has apparently evolved in conjunction with the sex-determining genetic loci.
Who came first, giant or dwarf?
The different reproductive roles of males and females, and of males belonging either to the nest-building or the parasitic type, suggest conflicting selective pressures yielding reproductive success dependent on body size. Concerning the male size-dimorphism, it is interesting to ponder over the most likely chronological order. Co-author Michael Taborsky proposes that giants preceded dwarfs: “The entire reproductive system of this species depends on the essential nest-building activity of giant males, who must be large enough to collect empty snail shells. The dwarf morph could then originate by a respective point mutation in the sex and size determining region of the genome, leading to a highly successful alternative reproductive tactic.”
Pooja Singh, Michael Taborsky, Catherine L. Peichel, Christian Sturmbauer
Institute of Ecology and Evolution
The Institute of Ecology & Evolution at the University of Bern is devoted to research and teaching in all aspects of ecology and evolution, and aims to provide a scientific basis for the understanding and preservation of our living world. It promotes the study of the mechanisms by which organisms respond to and interact with their environment, including phenotypic responses at individual level, change in gene frequencies at population level, change in species composition and abundance at community level, and the functioning of whole ecosystems.