How resistant cancer cells can be fought

An international research team under the co-direction of the University of Bern and the Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI) has discovered various mechanisms of resistance to cancer therapy. The findings help researchers to understand the self-repair of cancer cells after a therapy and thus help to fight resistant tumors more efficiently.

The DNA in our cells is constantly subjected to damage, caused in particular by the cells’ normal metabolism. Current estimates assume up to 70,000 impairments per cell per day. Healthy cells can repair this damage, however, using the proteins BRCA1 and BRCA2, for example. If they are defective though, this leads to an increased number of DNA mutations, which can cause cancer. Damage to these two repair proteins is associated above all with the occurrence of breast and ovarian cancer. Tumors with such a defect can be fought using a new therapy with so-called PARP inhibitors. If the protein PARP, which also plays a role in DNA repair, is blocked as well as the defective repair proteins, the cancer cells die off while the healthy body cells (with still functioning repair proteins) survive. Unfortunately, despite the clinical success of the PARP inhibitors, patients often develop a resistance. The precise causes for this resistance are still unclear.

In close cooperation with the Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI) in Amsterdam (Jonkers Laboratory), the Institute of Cancer Research in London (Lord Laboratory), the Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute in Toronto (Durocher Laboratory), and the Genome Integrity Laboratory in Oxford (Chapman Laboratory), a research team from the University of Bern has now identified four different resistance mechanisms against these PARP inhibitors. The findings can be used to develop new approaches for tackling therapy resistances. Thanks to this research, new insights have also been obtained into the fundamental mechanisms of DNA repair. The results have been published in the "Cancer Cell", "Cell Reports", and "Nature".

Millions of cancer cells examined

Using the gene scissors CRISPR/Cas9 and targeted silencing of genes, the researchers were able to find out which genes guide DNA repair in combination with the cancer therapy. They modified millions of BRCA-mutated cancer cells genetically, although they only changed an average of 1 gene per cell. These millions of cells were then treated with PARP inhibitors, and the cells that remained, having survived the treatment, were those which had become resistant due to certain genetic changes. "The changes in these cells then indicated to us which genes are involved in the development of a resistance", says Sven Rottenberg of the Vetsuisse Faculty at the University of Bern. In order to observe this, the researchers also cultivated the tumor cells in a three-dimensional matrix, which offers the advantage that these cell cultures are more similar to the real tumors (see Press release on 3D organoids of 11.12.2017). With these tests, the researchers discovered that the success of the PARP inhibitors depends on the functions of other proteins that are also involved in the repair of DNA breaks. If these (in part newly discovered) proteins are not functioning, resistance to PARP inhibitors develops.

Exploiting the tumors’ Achilles heel

New opportunities arise from understanding the exact resistance mechanisms: "In our models, we have seen that the tumors that are resistant to treatment by PARP inhibitors – due to the deficiency of other DNA repair proteins – can be fought with radiotherapy or already established anti-cancer drugs such as temozolamide. This opens up therapeutic options for patients in which the cancer has reappeared after an initially successful treatment with PARP inhibitors", explains Rottenberg. His research group is working on finding more weak points in the resistant tumors, with the hope of developing new therapeutic approaches and of overcoming the resistance shown by cancer that occurs due to defective repair proteins.

The research of Sven Rottenberg is supported by the Swiss National Science Fund (SNF), the Swiss Cancer League, the Dutch Cancer League (KWF), and the EU (European Research Council, ERC). The current study is a collaboration between the University of Bern and the Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI) in Amsterdam (Jonkers and Wessels Laboratories), the Institute of Cancer Research in London (Lord Laboratory), the Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute in Toronto (Durocher Laboratory) and the University of Zurich (Lopes Laboratory), the Danish Cancer Society Research Centre in Copenhagen and Karolinksa Institutes in Stockholm (Bartek Laboratories), the University of Oxford (Chapman and Tarsounas Laboratories), the University of Manchester (Ogilvie Laboratory), the University of Leiden (van Attikum Laboratory), and the University of Groningen (van Vugt Laboratory).

Publication details:

Gogola E, Duarte AA, de Ruiter JR, Wiegant WW, Schmid JA, James DI, Guerrero Llobet S, Vis DJ, Annunziato S, van den Broek B, Barazas M, Kersbergen A, de Bruijn R, van de Ven M, Tarsounas M, Ogilvie DJ, van Vugt M, Wessels LFA, Bartkova J, Gromova I, Andújar Sánchez M, Bartek J, Lopes M, van Attikum H, Borst P, Jonkers J, Rottenberg S. Selective loss of PARG restores PARylation and counteracts PARP inhibitor-mediated synthetic lethality. Cancer Cell, 11 June 2018, doi:

Barazas M, Annunziato S, Pettitt SJ, de Krijger I, Ghezraoui H, Roobol SJ, Lutz C, Frankum J, Song FF, Brough R, Evers B, Gogola E, Bhin J, van de Ven M, van Gent DC, Jacobs JJL, Chapman R, Lord CJ, Jonkers J, Rottenberg S. The CST Complex Mediates End Protection at Double-Strand Breaks and Promotes PARP Inhibitor Sensitivity in BRCA1-Deficient Cells. Cell Rep. 2018 15 May 2018; 23(7): 2107-2118.

Noordermeer SM, Adam S, Setiaputra D, Barazas M, Pettitt SJ, Ling AK, Olivieri M, Álvarez-Quilón A, Moatti N, Zimmermann M, Annunziato S, Krastev DB, Song F, Brandsma I, Frankum F, Brough R, Sherker A, Landry S, Szilard RK, Munro M, McEwan A, Goullet de Rugy T, Lin ZY, Hart T, Moffat J, Gingras AG, Martin A, van Attikum H, Jonkers J, Lord CJ, Rottenberg S, Durocher D. The Shieldin complex mediates 53BP1-dependent DNA repair. Nature 2018, 18 July 2018, doi: 10.1038/s41586-018-0340-7

Hind Ghezraoui, Catarina Oliveira, Jordan R. Becker, Kirstin Bilham, Daniela Moralli, Consuelo Anzilotti, Roman Fischer, Mukta Deobagkar-Lele, Maria Sanchiz-Calvo, Elena Fueyo-Marcos, Sarah Bonham, Benedikt M. Kessler, Sven Rottenberg, Richard J. Cornall, Catherine M. Green, J. Ross Chapman, 53BP1 cooperation with the REV7-shieldin complex underpins DNA structure-specific NHEJ, Nature 2018, 25 July 2018, doi: 10.1038/s41586-018-0362-1